Git Flow vs Trunk Based Development – 2 Methods! Choose Which One Is Suitable And Cool For You!

Git Flow vs Trunk Based Development
Share this post and Earn Free Points!

In this post I will dive into topic: Git Flow vs Trunk Based. Which one is better and which one is more convenient to use in development proces.

Introduction

Git

Git is a distributed version control system (DVCS) that enables developers to manage and track code changes across time. Linus Torvalds, the architect of the Linux operating system, invented it in 2005 as a mechanism to organise the Linux kernel source code. It has now become one of the most used version control systems in the software development industry.

Developers may collaborate on code with Git by generating distinct versions of the same codebase, known as branches. Each branch may be worked on concurrently by many developers, and modifications can be merged back into the main branch, known as “master” or “trunk,” when they are complete. This enables teams to work on multiple features or bug fixes concurrently without interfering with one another.

Developers may also rollback changes, compare multiple versions of code, and examine a history of all changes made to the source with Git. This makes it simple to trace defects, determine when they were introduced, and reverse modifications as needed.

Furthermore, because Git is a distributed version control system, each developer has a local copy of the complete codebase and its history, allowing them to work offline and contribute to their own repository. This allows developers to operate remotely or in disconnected situations with ease.

GitHub is a prominent Git hosting platform that offers a web-based interface for developers to collaborate, distribute, and manage their code. Similar capability is provided by other systems such as GitLab, Bitbucket, and Azure DevOps.

Git Flow

Git Flow is a Git, a distributed version control system, branching model. Vincent Driessen developed it as an addition to the Git branching paradigm, and it has since become a popular method of managing software development projects.

Git Flow offers a set of specified protocols for managing various sorts of branches, including feature branches, release branches, and hotfix branches. It also contains instructions for merging, releasing, and deploying code.

By adhering to these procedures, developers may collaborate more effectively while still maintaining a uniform and structured codebase.

Git Flow Diagram

The basic Git Flow diagram consists of five types of branches:

  1. Master: The main branch that contains the stable, production-ready code. Only the final, tested, and approved versions of features are merged into the master branch.
  2. Develop: The branch that contains the latest development changes. All feature branches are merged into the develop branch.
  3. Feature: A branch created for a specific feature that is being developed. It is created from the develop branch and merged back into it when the feature is complete.
  4. Release: A branch created to prepare for a new release. It is created from the develop branch and contains all the features that will be included in the release. It is merged into the master branch when the release is ready.
  5. Hotfix: A branch created to quickly fix a critical bug in the production code. It is created from the master branch and merged back into it when the bug is fixed.

Please find who the Git Flow diagram looks like:

Git Flow vs Trunk Based, git flow diagram
Git Flow Diagram

Trunk Based

Trunk-based development is a method of developing software that emphasises the usage of a single primary development branch, commonly known as the trunk or master branch. All developers work on the trunk under this manner, committing their changes directly to it and integrating modifications from other developers on a regular basis. In contrast, more complicated branching models, such as Git Flow, employ many branches for distinct phases of development.

Trunk-based development is intended to be simple, quick, and simple to comprehend. It encourages developers to commit early and frequently, as well as to settle issues as they arise. This reduces the likelihood of integration difficulties and makes it easier to recover from errors. It also enables faster feedback, less code review, and fewer merge conflicts.

Git Flow vs Trunk Based

Git Flow and Trunk-based development are two ways to branch management in a Git repository. Both have their own set of benefits and drawbacks.

Git Flow Pros

  • Provides a clear and defined process for managing different types of branches, such as feature branches, release branches, and hotfix branches.
  • Helps to maintain a consistent and organized codebase.
  • Allows for more effective collaboration among developers.
  • Clear distinction between development and production code

Git Flow Cons

  • It can be more difficult to comprehend and apply than other branching models. Because of the amount of branches involved, merging and releasing code might take longer.
  • If not followed appropriately, might result in merge conflicts and integration difficulties.

Trunk Based Pros

  • Simple, fast and easy to understand.
  • Encourages developers to commit early and often, and to resolve conflicts as soon as they arise.
  • Allows for faster feedback, less code review and fewer merge conflicts
  • less overhead and less administration

Trunk Based Cons

  • Lack of clear distinction between development and production code
  • It can be harder to manage complex or long-running features, and releases
  • Less flexibility for different team structures or projects
  • Risk of breaking the build or deployment process if not followed correctly

Development Team Size

In terms of the number of development team members, Git Flow can be useful in bigger teams since it provides a clear and defined approach for managing different sorts of branches and aids in the maintenance of a consistent and ordered codebase. This enables numerous developers to work on various features or bug fixes concurrently without interfering with one another. Furthermore, properly separating development, testing, and production code helps to minimise integration difficulties and promotes release predictability.

Trunk-based development, on the other hand, is better suited for smaller teams or teams where developers are expected to work alone and assume complete ownership of their code. It encourages developers to commit early and frequently, as well as to address disputes as they emerge, lowering the chance of integration difficulties and making it simpler to recover from mistakes. It also enables faster feedback, less code review, and fewer merge conflicts.

It’s also worth noting that some teams may choose for a hybrid strategy, using the best practises from both models and tailoring them to their own goals and limits. For example, for small projects, use trunk-based development and Git Flow for bigger projects.

Summary

Finally, the decision between GF and TB development is dictated by the unique demands and limits of your team and project. Both techniques have been used effectively in different circumstances, and the ideal strategy will rely on aspects such as team size and structure, codebase complexity, and project specific requirements.

Overall, Git is a robust and adaptable platform that allows developers to collaborate more efficiently and effectively, and it has become an indispensable tool for modern software development.

Finally, the decision between GF and TB development is influenced by the unique demands and limits of your team and project. Before making a selection, thoroughly analyse the pros and disadvantages of each strategy, as well as the unique demands of your team and project.

Could You Please Share This Post? 
I appreciate It And Thank YOU! :)
Have A Nice Day!

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 5 / 5. Vote count: 1

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

As you found this post useful...

Follow us on social media!

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?